Environment / March 13, 2025

Is Mark Carney a Climate Radical?

Canada’s prime minister–designate backs the science that says most fossil fuel can’t be burned.

Mark Hertsgaard
(Artur Widak / NurPhoto / Getty Images)

The business beat has long been an ideal perch for reporting the climate story, and it’s doubly so now that Mark Carney is becoming the new prime minister of Canada. Initial reporting on Carney replacing Justin Trudeau as the Liberal Party leader and designated prime minister focused on the implications for Canada’s trade war with the United States, where President Donald Trump on Tuesday repeated his increasingly aggressive threats to annex the US’s neighbor, saying the only way for Canada to avoid Trump’s tariffs “is for the country to ‘become our cherished Fifty-First State,’” the CBC reported.

What hasn’t yet gotten much press attention are Carney’s views about climate change and fossil fuels, which are commendably grounded in science but carry radical political and economic implications. Over the past decade, Carney has repeatedly stated that the vast majority of Earth’s remaining reserves of oil, gas, and coal must be left in the ground, unburned—because burning them would risk a catastrophic overheating of the planet. The world’s climate scientists have been saying exactly that with increasing urgency for years. But leaving most fossil fuels in the ground poses enormous practical challenges for Canada, one of the world’s foremost producers and exporters of oil and gas. It also could be another flash point between Canada and the US, which now is led by an administration promoting climate-change denial.

With new elections expected very soon in Canada, this consequential twist in the climate story cries out for fresh reporting. Canada’s opposition parties will call for a vote of no confidence when parliament resumes on March 24; if the vote passes, Canadians would return to the polls, probably by early May. As Carney faces voters, reporters might well ask if he still believes that most fossil fuels must be left unburned. And if so, how does he plan to pursue that vision when fossil fuels are such a big part of Canada’s economy?

In a landmark speech he gave as the head of the Bank of England in 2015, Carney warned that excessive investment in fossil fuels threatened a repeat of the 2008 global financial collapse. The International Energy Agency had recently concluded that only about one-third of the world’s remaining oil, gas, and coal reserves could be burned without pushing temperature rise beyond 2 degrees Celsius, at the time the accepted threshold for avoiding disaster. In financial terms, that would make the remaining two-thirds of reserves all but worthless “stranded” assets. But fossil fuel companies counted those reserves as genuine wealth, as did insurance companies, banks, and pension funds that invested in those companies. That mismatch amounted to a carbon bubble, similar to the housing bubble that triggered the 2008 financial collapse.

To keep that carbon bubble from bursting, Carney went on to order British banks to undergo climate stress tests—theoretical exercises to check if banks could remain solvent if most fossil fuels became stranded assets. The practical effect was to encourage a shift away from fossil fuels. Carney has continued this approach in recent years as the UN Special Envoy for Climate Action and Finance. With the temperature target now tightened to 1.5 degrees C, he endorsed a November 2023 report by the Energy Transitions Committee that concluded that “65% of all oil and gas reserves and 90% of all coal reserves must be left in the ground…. and there is no need for any exploration of new oil and gas fields.”

On the campaign trail, Carney responded to Conservative Party attacks by promising to “end the consumer carbon tax” Trudeau had implemented, “meaning Canadians would no longer pay a tax when they fill up their petrol tanks or heat their homes. Instead, the burden would shift to corporate polluters,” the Times of London reported. How such a policy would affect the larger scientific imperative of leaving fossil fuels in the ground is unclear. But, unlike many world leaders, Carney plainly takes climate science seriously and has thought hard about how it should guide policy. How the former central banker explains his vision to Canada’s voters during the upcoming election campaign and perhaps again as the prime minister is a story not only for environmental reporters but for their colleagues on the business, politics, and international affairs desks as well.

Mark Hertsgaard

Mark Hertsgaard is the environment correspondent of The Nation and the executive director of the global media collaboration Covering Climate Now. His new book is Big Red’s Mercy:  The Shooting of Deborah Cotton and A Story of Race in America.

More from The Nation

The full moon rises over the cooling towers of the Trillo Nuclear Power Plant in Guadalajara, Spain.

The False Promise of Nuclear Power The False Promise of Nuclear Power

A new book by Joe Romm explains why nuclear is not much of a climate solution.

Mark Hertsgaard

Warren Buffett, chairman of Berkshire Hathaway, tours the exhibition floor prior to the Berkshire Hathaway shareholders meeting in Omaha, Nebraska, on May 3, 2014.

Warren Buffett Is a Climate-Wrecker Warren Buffett Is a Climate-Wrecker

Los Angeles Times climate columnist Sammy Roth scoops his business beat colleagues.

Mark Hertsgaard

The Climate Costs of Occupation

The Climate Costs of Occupation The Climate Costs of Occupation

As Israel expands its settlements in the West Bank, it has destroyed forests and boosted CO2 emissions.

Haitham Al-Sharif

A green lantern was lit in the steeple of the Old North Church in Boston to announce a day of action—Sun Day—to celebrate that we no longer need fossil fuels.

We Can Run the World Without Fossil Fuels We Can Run the World Without Fossil Fuels

By lighting a green lantern in Boston’s Old North Church, environmentalists announce a new global day of action—Sun Day—to celebrate a world that no longer needs fossil fuels.

Mark Hertsgaard and Bill McKibben

Harmony Cummings holds a sign outside the office of Senator John Hickenlooper (D-CO) during a Time to Thrive rally organized by the Colorado Green New Deal coalition to demand support for the THRIVE act on March 31, 2021, in Denver.

A Silent Climate Majority A Silent Climate Majority

Most of the world’s people want stronger climate action—but don’t realize they’re the majority.

Mark Hertsgaard and Kyle Pope

A man holds a placard reading

The Game-Changing Truth That Could Save the Planet The Game-Changing Truth That Could Save the Planet

Dispelling the myth that climate action is unpopular could push the world over a social tipping point and lead to unstoppable progress.

Damian Carrington